One of the most important responsibilities for a camp director is to develop good Boards of Managers and facilitate their growth. Strong camp boards are vital to a camps growth and development. Here are some of my thoughts about developing and managing good boards and committees.
Historically the relationship between volunteers and professional YMCA staff has been very strong and important to the organization—one of the Y’s greatest strengths. Balance is most important, if the relationship is dominated by either side there can be trouble. The Y is still very much a “bottom up” type lay organization, reflected by the fact that it took 30 years to hire the first professional person after the founding in 1844.
Though Y professionals and lay Boards and Committees work together there is a chasm between them that neither side crosses. Lay people report to lay people and professional Y staff report to professional staff, there is no mixing on this point. That said, if there is a professional vacancy to be filled lay people can be involved in the search process but the decision is made by supervising professional staff. By the same token lay Boards of Managers choose their own chairman.
The chairman of a Board is the person that volunteer leaders report to. Also, lay members of Boards and Committees recruit other lay members. The chairman of a Board is the one who selects the chair of the Boards that report to them. So for instance, the chairman of the Greater Twin Cities YMCA is the one who selects the Board chairmen for each of the branches which also includes the camps.
Composing boards of managers
I think it’s essential to compose a camp board representing two groups of people; people who are familiar with the camp from personal experience and people who are business community leaders not necessarily related to the camp. For those related to the camp I tried to encourage parents of campers, especially those also tied to the corporate community. I also liked the idea of having people on the Board who were once campers who grew up in the program.
When we started girls programing at Widji I felt it was important that women should also be included on the Widji Board and it turned out that the first three women on the Board were mothers of campers. Widjiwagan was the first Branch Board to include women within the entire Board structure of what was then the St. Paul YMCA.
During my time as the camp’s director there were Board members who were corporate officers in the companies they worked for. We also thought it would be good to include directors of foundations but they shied away from identity with any one group.
My role as Widji’s director
There are two things that come to mind about my role in working with the Board. I considered it was part of my job to help identify and recommend people who would make good Board members, though it wasn’t my job to ask them to join.
I also thought it was my job to help keep the Board motivated and involved. Organizing a weekend meeting of the Board at Widji each year was one important way to do this. The Board felt closer to camp as a result of being there and seeing it firsthand. There were other ways too. The Explorer and Voyageur programs were motivating for the Board and so were the fund raising efforts to support the camp. Widji was the first branch camp at the St Paul Y to start an annual sustaining fund raising program. Axel Von Bergen was the first chairman of the event and he chaired it for several succeeding years. His first campaign raised $1300 and now they raise several thousand dollars each year. Sometimes their campaigns made a special case for raising funds by stating a particular need for something. Campaigns served several general purposes: they help keep operating expenses down, provide financial assistance to needy campers, and help with needed physical improvements.
The Boards role
Generally speaking the Board is responsible to create policies and practices which professional staff are responsible to carry out. To do this there are several committees and it starts with the executive committee. Some of the standing committees on the Boards I worked with included:
- The Buildings and Grounds committee. They survey camp physical needs, getting a firsthand look when they are on-site for the annual weekend meeting at camp.
- Board and Committee Cultivation. They met every nine months to consider candidates for all Board and Committee positions, which also includes the chairman of the Board position.
- Fund Raising. They have responsibility for all annual fund raising. I think every Board member should be involved in annual fund raising events. It gives them an opportunity to meet people and often there is good feedback from prospects. This committee also helps with Capital Campaign efforts—big challenges for the lay structure.
- Program committee. I thought the vice-chairman of the Board should also be the Program Committee chairman. This committee formulates and approves all the programs of the camp. This included the Voyageurs and Explorers program, leadership ratios to the size of groups, the minimum age of campers, the length of camper sessions, etc.,
- Ad Hoc Committees are appointed whenever a special task comes up.
Board committees all report to the Executive Committee and to the Chairman of the Board. This is part of the practice of lay people reporting to lay people. I think it’s good for as many Board members as possible to be active on committees and these meetings should occur before Board meetings.
The longer a camp operates the more Board positions can be filled from within. Widji and duNord each have strong Boards with several generations of families being involved now, adding to their strength. The camps also have strong professional leadership who understand the value of having strong Boards and Committees.