It should be remembered that in the beginning the YMCA was organized around men’s and boy’s programs. The founder of the YMCA, George Williams, was focusing on rural young men coming to London during the industrial revolution. The earliest records seem to indicate that the Y camping movement in the United States was the first to introduce girls programs to the Y and that happened in the mid-1930’s among the local YMCA’s.
At Widji there is early evidence of young adult canoe trips that included women for tripping only. I know that Hal Ponthon, one of the early counselors at Widji, met his wife on one such trip.
When Bob Nankivell became the camp director he looked for ways to increase the enrollment of the camp. In an effort to encourage local attendance he changed the schedule to include two four-week sessions for boys and one two-week session for girls. So the first girl’s session, as a regular part of the camp schedule happened in 1947 and in 1948 Joy Van, a life-long lay person associated with Widji, became a counselor for the second girl’s trip. She was a counselor again in 1949 for a group of nine girls that included two male guides. By making these changes Nankivell was emulating the successful program format of YMCA Camp Manitowish in Wisconsin.
Developing girls programs
When I became the camp director in 1951 I thought a lot about girls programing. Private camps were the first to do coed camping, followed by the church camping movement which provided in-town and out-of-town coed experiences. There was some talk in the early 50’s among Widji Board members that we might also provide coed tripping. But I resisted this idea and it never came to a vote. I felt that girls programing would never be developed on its own if we did this, girls needed to relate to girls and boys to boys. So much of our society already provides co-ed experiences. Our objective is for girls to have the same opportunity that the boys have.
Growing leadership
When I became the camp director in 1951 there were two boys’ five week sessions and one girls two week session.
The girls program quickly grew into two sessions lasting two weeks. A normal trip was ten girls, one woman cabin counselor and one male guide using four canoes. In addition to the regular sessions for boys and girls, Camp Widjiwagan provided a special “Outside” canoe trip service to many other YMCA’s and youth serving organizations: training, menu planning, trip determination, and equipment. As camp enrollment increased, these services to outside groups have become less.
In my mind I always wanted girl’s trips to go on the trail without a male guide but as with boys trips there was always a balancing act; the ability and experience of the counselor and the ability and experience of the group determined how long and how difficult a trip would be.
In earlier years I didn’t feel we could send a girl’s counselor out on the trail alone until we had women counselors who could do it. The first girls’ cabin counselor I had confidence in was Lois Eyinck who demonstrated she was very able in many ways. Her first trip was in 1954. Helen Berg and Ann Haugan were also among the first women’s staff to take trips out alone. A contributing factor was due to the skill level of the returning campers.
The first boys Voyageur trip went out in 1955 and the first girls Voyageur trip went out in 1956, again under Lois’s leadership.
It was just a matter of time before enough women becoming cabin/trail counselors trained to go out on the trail without male guides and by 1962, when I left Widji as its director, no girls trips included male guides anymore.
Should girls go on trips without male guides?
When we made the initial decision to send girls trips out without male guides there were some women (mothers) on the Widji Board who wondered if this was a good idea. There was fear that men on the trail would bother girls groups—sometimes male groups think society rules change when they are in the wilderness. There was some justification for these fears and over the years there have been times when women counselors found themselves in difficult situations with male groups, but fortunately the girls and counselors have handled these situations well. As the idea of having girls travel alone was a rather unique experience at that time, just before the Boundary Waters were formalized. Today girls’ trips are more common.
I also know that some women who accepted counselor and Voyageur positions were sometimes overwhelmed by the decision to say “yes” because they are accepting a lot of responsibility. But today we seem to have a wonderful back-log of women counselors taking canoe and back-packing trips.
Widji has a strong girls program now and the uniqueness of doing it alone is valuable. I believe we made right decisions but I worried about them for a long time, and still do, as I do with boys’ trips too. I will always hope and pray for their safety.