Working with people and managing their efforts is a complicated process. I think staff management has three basic components: hiring, training, and supervision. So here are some things I think are important considerations in each of these areas.
Hiring
In the best of all worlds leadership comes from within and Widji is very fortunate to be able to hire staffs who were once Widji campers. As staff members they already have wilderness camping and tripping skills and know Widji’s culture. Hiring camp counselors who grew up in the program also gives camp directors information about who they are as persons too. When I became the camp’s director in 1951 there were some staff who came through the program but I also had to hired people who didn’t have previous experience with the camp.
One of my rules was always to conduct a personal interview and I also required personal written references. The process today seems to rely more on verbal communication.
I looked for two abilities in perspective staff; good camping and trail skills and good people working skills. There were times when I had to pick between the two and at such times I always chose good counseling skills because I thought it would be easier to teach trail skills. Most important was to know if a person felt comfortable working with boys or girls and I depended on references and a personal interview to provide this information. Later on as more Widji campers applied to become counselors we were able to know beforehand about their trail skills and that was helpful.
Staff training
Training is important and we devoted five to seven days to staff training before camp started each year. If a person was lacking in camping and trail skills this is where we started to train them—climaxing with a two or three day break-in trip which also gave us information about each person’s abilities. Staff training also focused on counseling skills, encouraging people to think about how to lead groups and work with campers. I also involved outside experts such as Milt Stenland from the DNR in Ely to take the staff on field trips to learn more about the natural habitat. We also brought in experts to help focus more on staff/camper relationships.
The staff training period also helped us match staff abilities with those of the campers who were returning for a second or third experience at Widji. These campers returned expecting longer and more demanding trips so we had to send them out with staff with those skills.
At this time we also learned more about staff preferences too. For instance, I remember one returning staff member who preferred to work with younger children (most wanted to take out older groups on longer more involved trips) and we were happy to honor that.
Managing and supervising
One way to visualize the counselor/camper relationship is to draw a circle around the campers. The question is where the counselor should be. They can be completely outside the circle, have one foot inside the circle and one out, or be completely inside the circle. If they are entirely inside or outside the circle they risk losing control of the group. For instance, if a counselor chooses to be inside the circle it’s an indication that they want to be friends with everyone and they choose not to use their authority. But being a group counselor is a lot like being a parent, one should have one foot in the circle to identify and share warmth with campers but the other foot should be outside so as to be able to exercise the authority of their position when it’s needed.
As the camp director my role with counselors was similar to what theirs was with campers, I had to keep one foot on either side of the line. Every now and then I organized social events for staff that happened to be in camp. We went to the resort on Big Lake where the owner had good cooking skills on the grill, or we had ice cream socials at the director’s cabin after it was built. There were evenings at Doc Venebal’s home too (the camp doctor).
One of my personal rules was not to “expect what you don’t inspect.” It means that when you give a responsibility you must also inspect to see what level it’s being done. I think the camp director must be seen and must be out and about to listen, inspect, and know what is happening. But I had to respect the right of staff such as the trail director and the cook to supervise the staff that was under them too. I was careful not to go around them to supervise their staffs.
When counselors came back from their trips it was important for me to sit down with them to hear about their trips, what happened that was special, and who the strong campers were. It was a place for counselors to discuss their issues too.
Good management included the goal of good staff growth and development.
Changing directors
When a person of tenure leaves their position the person replacing them typically doesn’t have an easy first year, established loyalties can get in the way. People have to make adjustments to different styles of management and communication. This is also the case for professionals in YMCA’s too.